Skip to main content

Clients ask us this question almost every week. They have read that one brand is the best, and they want to know if the other brand will let them down. We paint with both, on real jobs across Metro Vancouver, so here is the honest answer we give in person.

Both brands make good paint

There is no bad choice at the top of either range. Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams both make paints that cover well, hold their colour, and last for years when the prep is done right.

Benjamin Moore has earned its name with rich colours and a smooth finish. Designers love it, and many colour palettes start as Benjamin Moore colours. Sherwin Williams is the workhorse of the painting trade. Its premium lines are on more homes in North America than any other brand, and contractors trust them because they behave the same way on every job.

If a painter tells you one of these brands is garbage, he is selling you something. Both are good materials. The real difference is not quality. It is price, and where that price comes from.

Where the price difference comes from

Paint stores give professional painters a contractor discount, and the two brands do not give the same one.

Sherwin Williams gives painters a discount of about 50 percent off the shelf price. That is a big reason our standard quotes can include premium paint without the material line scaring anyone. Benjamin Moore gives painters a much smaller discount. The paint itself also tends to sit at a higher shelf price.

So for the same house, the same number of gallons, and the same two coats, Benjamin Moore simply costs more to buy. On a full home repaint that difference adds up to real money, and it is the client who pays it, because the material goes into the quote. You can see how materials fit into a painting quote on our painting costs page.

Does the more expensive paint look better?

This is the part nobody in a paint store will tell you. The finished wall does not know what the can cost.

What decides how a room looks is the work under the paint. Walls patched and sanded smooth. The right primer on repairs and stains. Two full coats, cut clean and rolled evenly. Our paint finish guide explains how much of the result is the finish and the prep rather than the brand.

A well prepared wall painted with Sherwin Williams looks excellent, full stop. A badly prepared wall painted with the most expensive Benjamin Moore line still shows every patch and roller line. You are paying for the painter far more than for the logo on the can.

Deep green panelled accent wall and fireplace painted by Exceptional Painting in Vancouver

There are jobs where Benjamin Moore is the right call. If a designer has built the whole colour scheme around a Benjamin Moore colour and finish, matching it exactly matters, and we paint with it gladly. Most Benjamin Moore colours can also be mixed into Sherwin Williams paint, which gives you the colour you fell in love with at the lower material cost.

What we use every day

Our standard wall paint is Sherwin Williams SuperPaint in a velvet type finish. We use it in houses and condos across Metro Vancouver because it covers well, touches up cleanly, and holds up in busy family homes. SuperPaint also carries a lifetime warranty from the manufacturer, and our own workmanship warranty is three years.

Bedroom with soft sage green walls and white trim in a Vancouver home

When a client or a designer specifies Benjamin Moore for a project, we say yes and price the material honestly, so you see the difference before you decide. That happens on our interior painting work more often than you might think, and the finished rooms look great either way.

So which one should you choose?

If you love a Benjamin Moore colour, keep it. The colour matters more than the brand, and we can usually mix it into Sherwin Williams and save you the material difference.

If you are choosing on value, Sherwin Williams gives you a premium result without the premium material bill, because the contractor discount is passed into your quote.

Either way, spend your attention on the painter, not the paint. Ask who does the prep, how many coats are included, and what warranty stands behind the work.

Get a detailed estimate

If you are planning a repaint and want straight advice on paint, call Exceptional Painting at (236) 995-6777. We will look at your home, talk through the colours and the brands with no pressure, and give you one clear total.

We have been painting homes and condos in Metro Vancouver since 2012. We are fully insured, with $5 million in liability coverage and WCB, and every job carries our three year workmanship warranty.

Leave a Reply

Call Now (236) 995-6777